Thursday, September 1, 2011

9/1 - Class: Your brain on the internet.

..."The depth of our intelligence hinges on our ability to transfer information from working memory, the scratch pad of consciousness, to long-term memory, the mind’s filing system."
The following are some points I think are important to think about after reading Author Nicholas Carr: The Web Shatters Focus, Rewires Brains .

For homework, please respond to the text preceeding one of these numbers in brackets. Be as detailed as possible.

[1] "Brain activity of the experienced surfers was far more extensive than that of the newbies, particularly in areas of the prefrontal cortex associated with problem-solving and decisionmaking."
[2] "The new scans revealed that their brain activity had changed dramatically; it now resembled that of the veteran surfers. 'Five hours on the Internet and the naive subjects had already rewired their brains,'"
[3] "'The current explosion of digital technology not only is changing the way we live and communicate,' Small concluded, “but is rapidly and profoundly altering our brains.'"
[4] "Many educators were convinced that introducing hyperlinks into text displayed on monitors would be a boon to learning. Hypertext would strengthen critical thinking, the argument went, by enabling students to switch easily between different viewpoints. Freed from the lockstep reading demanded by printed pages, readers would make all sorts of new intellectual connections between diverse works. The hyperlink would be a technology of liberation."

What is hypertext??

[5] "By the end of the decade, the enthusiasm was turning to skepticism. Research was painting a fuller, very different picture of the cognitive effects of hypertext. Navigating linked documents, it turned out, entails a lot of mental calisthenics—evaluating hyperlinks, deciding whether to click, adjusting to different formats—that are extraneous to the process of reading. Because it disrupts concentration, such activity weakens comprehension. A 1989 study showed that readers tended just to click around aimlessly when reading something that included hypertext links to other selected pieces of information. A 1990 experiment revealed that some 'could not remember what they had and had not read.'"
[6] "A 2007 scholarly review of hypertext experiments concluded that jumping between digital documents impedes understanding. And if links are bad for concentration and comprehension, it shouldn’t be surprising that more recent research suggests that links surrounded by images, videos, and advertisements could be even worse."
[7] "The Net’s ability to monitor events and send out messages and notifications automatically is, of course, one of its great strengths as a communication technology. We rely on that capability to personalize the workings of the system, to program the vast database to respond to our particular needs, interests, and desires. We want to be interrupted, because each interruption—email, tweet, instant message, RSS headline—brings us a valuable piece of information. To turn off these alerts is to risk feeling out of touch or even socially isolated. The stream of new information also plays to our natural tendency to overemphasize the immediate. We crave the new even when we know it’s trivial."
[8] "It’s likely that Web browsing also strengthens brain functions related to fast-paced problem-solving, particularly when it requires spotting patterns in a welter of data. A British study of the way women search for medical information online indicated that an experienced Internet user can, at least in some cases, assess the trustworthiness and probable value of a Web page in a matter of seconds. The more we practice surfing and scanning, the more adept our brain becomes at those tasks. (Other academics, like Clay Shirky, maintain that the Web provides us with a valuable outlet for a growing “cognitive surplus”; see Cognitive Surplus: The Great Spare-Time Revolution."
[9] "We know that the human brain is highly plastic; neurons and synapses change as circumstances change. When we adapt to a new cultural phenomenon, including the use of a new medium, we end up with a different brain, says Michael Merzenich, a pioneer of the field of neuroplasticity. That means our online habits continue to reverberate in the workings of our brain cells even when we’re not at a computer. We’re exercising the neural circuits devoted to skimming and multitasking while ignoring those used for reading and thinking deeply."
[10] "There’s nothing wrong with absorbing information quickly and in bits and pieces. We’ve always skimmed newspapers more than we’ve read them, and we routinely run our eyes over books and magazines to get the gist of a piece of writing and decide whether it warrants more thorough reading. The ability to scan and browse is as important as the ability to read deeply and think attentively. The problem is that skimming is becoming our dominant mode of thought. Once a means to an end, a way to identify information for further study, it’s becoming an end in itself—our preferred method of both learning and analysis. Dazzled by the Net’s treasures, we are blind to the damage we may be doing to our intellectual lives and even our culture."

19 comments:

  1. It's crazy how the internet effects our brain. I had no idea the internet did this too us!

    ReplyDelete
  2. In bracket number 2 it states how easy it is to get around the internet.I agree with this statement completely based on the time I had taught my mother how to use the internet for shopping online,and how quickly she was able to maneuver around each website.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In number five it talks about pretty much being distracted on the internet. I completely agree with this statement because i can relate. when I'm using the internet, specifically for research, it is so hard to concentrate on reading the material with all the ads, and the "Click here to win a billion gazillion dollars" popping up everywhere.

    ReplyDelete
  4. @James, have you seen any changes in how you think? (Nicholas Carr writes about Neural Plasticity... do you think we can change how we think?)

    @Shanice, but I have had a different experience with my parents! I cannot show them how to use a computer! They forget everything I show them. What does that say about them? What makes them unable to use the computer?

    @Riana, how specifically are you distracted? Why are ads, such as "Click here to win a billion gazillion dollars" ads, so distracting? Do you think everyone has an ad, or type of ad, that can distract you?

    Does anyone else know of a specific type of ad that distracts?

    ReplyDelete
  5. In reference to [4], i find that when i click on a hyperlink i ignore/forget/lose interest in the original content. If anything it increased my short attention span. Overall i guess people do collect more info but if theyre thrown all this additional information thats branching out it wears out ones patience and limits anyone from thinking in a deep manner. So the said educators were partially right in that it did increase learning but not the critical thinking part.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think it is so amazing how technology such as the internet is created and changes the lives of ourselves and everyone around us. As said in the third quote, the internet plays a big role in our generation, not only changing the way we think, but all how we think. The internet is a great invention, but it also has its pros and cons.

    ReplyDelete
  7. [6] Hypertext only distract people from what they are originally reading. To be in the middle of something and then get lead to something completely different, even if it's connected to the original text, is going to jumble up the info. you're trying to process. Now with even more ads that are across the top, between the text you're reading and even video ads (which i hate deeply) do nothing but distract and throw us off course.

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Riana, how specifically are you distracted? Why are ads, such as "Click here to win a billion gazillion dollars" ads, so distracting? Do you think everyone has an ad, or type of ad, that can distract you?
    @Prof. Navarro - Well not only are they super duper annoying, they interrupt the reading process. It makes it so hard to concentrate on the material and take it all in. Ads pop up on the screen, forcing you to stop reading, then you have to ex them out. Now, you have to go back, look for where you left off. At this point, you probably forgot what previously read so now you have to reread what you already read just get the gist of it all again so you won't be lost. It is EXHAUSTING and greatly extends the process. And if you are stupid enough to click the "YES! I'm interested!" button then 9 times out of 10 you will either get a virus, an identity theft case, or your computer will be bombarded with spam. In my opinion, YES THEY ARE ALL IRRITATING!!! Especially the video ads, they give the "OMG!!! KILL ME" feeling. I rest my case =]

    ReplyDelete
  9. It is astonishing how technology has progressed in the past two decades. We came from huge colorless brick like cell phones to small smart phones which have the similar capabilities with modern computers. Most people could not even imagine living with out the type of technology we got now a days, and because of it as it hints in the [3] reference, our brains are slowly degrading. People are getting dumber by relying on technology, but as always there are Pros and Cons to everything.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I found [7] very interesting. "We want to be interrupted, to turn off these alerts is to risk feeling out of touch or even socially isolated." These quotes have so much truth to them, I'm not a fan of Facebook or any of those type of sites but when I am in the middle of homework that is when I tend to go on the most. For a short while I'm very focused on my work but then I feel very interested on what's going on around me. I'll read comments of other people posting how bored they are doing their own work instead of just focusing and finishing my own.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I found [10] stuck in my head as I read the article. "The problem is that skimming is becoming our dominant mode of thought." This quote is very true! We are losing grasp on how to think deeply. I even catch myself skimming through my textbooks and then not being able to remember half of the material within 15 minutes. It's very frustrating that our minds are programmed a bit to do this

    ReplyDelete
  12. @Professor Navarro, I think what makes them unable to use the internet, is so much information is given to them all at once that its much harder to retain.

    ReplyDelete
  13. As stated by all of these brackets that the internet has effected our brain processes of certain tasks and the routine of daily life. There are pros and cons to each argument. Its crazy how we have all adapted to the internet [9]. All this happened as an unintended consequence I highly doubt people sitting on the computer surfing the web are thinking " hey this is rewiring my brain " .The pace of change happened rather quickly. Nowadays if you don't know how to work the internet you are considered an outcast from society. Internet was a great advancement to society but there are always going to be downfalls.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I completely agree with point six which states that: "jumping between documents impedes understanding" because it is 100% true for me. Furthermore, links and ads are also distracting, not to mention annoying, when they keep popping up all the time.

    ReplyDelete
  15. According to [7], yes i do agree that "the internet's ability to monitor events, send out messages and notifications automatically are cool". Personificationally speaking, the internet also has the ability to control how we gather information. I hate being interrupted. Especially, the interruptions where they say you've won a prize. I actually be thinking I won a prize. I do not have Facebook or Twitter. Besides,I do not feel isolated by not having either of those websites.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I fully agree with the message displayed in [10]. Very rarely when I do research, do I read the whole article. Even though I know it is not the right way to do research it is much quicker to just skim through an article and obtain only the main point. I feel that articles may need to be shortened because peoples research habits will not change

    ReplyDelete
  17. I can really associate with [10]. If I need to read something for school on the internet, I'll quickly skim it to get the gist of what I am reading. It's convenient, but then again I won't remember what I am reading too well. It is hard for me to read things via computer, I get easily distracted compared to if I read a hard copy of something.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I agree with [3] to a certain extent. When anyone thinks about the internet the first thing that comes to mind, of course, is social networking. The purpose of social networking is to get into contact and socialize with other people whether familiar or not. without the new found advancements you may even communicate with people through webcam. I do disagree with the statement, “but is rapidly and profoundly altering our brains.'" I disagree because i don't think much has changed in the minds of the children of today to the children of the 1400s. The only difference is we are learning a new way to live.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I agree with number seven. As I was reading through this article I had Facebook pop up on my phone and also on my browser. While checking these notifications you get distracted by what everyone else is posting. When your doing your homework you would rather be reading through everyone else's conversations or flipping through pictures from last week than doing your homework.

    ReplyDelete